Vol 65, No 5 (2021)

Cover Page

HEALTH CARE ORGANIZATION

The impact of electronic medical records in the modern primary health care system on the interaction between doctor and patient in Moscow

Veselkova A.Y., Zvonareva E.S., Kornilov M.N., Ushenin V.V., Kornilova E.B., Hołownia-Voloskova M.E.

Abstract

Introduction. Digital technologies are an essential condition for the development of modern health care. New forms of interaction between the supplier and the consumer of medical services determine the need to understand the attitude of the doctor and the patient to this employment operation.

Purpose. Assess the change in the quality of communications between the doctor and the patient with the widespread introduction of electronic medical records. 

Material and methods. Within the framework of the project, a content analysis of media materials was held. Mass (questionnaire) survey of doctors and patients in November–December 2020 was executed. The comprehensive survey had 482 respondents, including 168 doctors and 314 patients.

Results. Most (61.5%) of medical professionals indicate a decrease in time costs during the patient’s reception, an increase in time to work with patients is noted in 47.4% of respondents. 55% of doctors report that the service helps better focus on the provision of medical care, and 47.6% of respondents believe that the conduct of medical documentation in electronic form allows reducing the frequency of passing a significant pathology. Among patients, 52.2% believe that introducing electronic medical records will enable you to increase the time that the doctor pays to the patient during the reception. 68.9% of patients indicate an improvement in the interaction between doctors and patients.

Conclusion. High-quality results can be achieved only if there is a medical staff with the skills of using modern digital technologies and new communication skills with a patient when using electronic medical records.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):405-410
pages 405-410 views

The value of an integrated approach to assessing the availability of primary health care, taking into account public opinion and EMIAS data

Budarin S.S., Starshinin A.V., Tyazhelnikov A.A., Kostenko E.V., Elbek Y.V.

Abstract

Introduction. The study of public opinion as the basis for strategic planning of the activities of medical institutions is more relevant than ever, as it allows finding ways to solve the problems of ensuring the availability and satisfaction of citizens with medical care.

Purpose. Comparative assessment of the availability of primary health care based on the results of a sociological study of public opinion and data from the Unified Medical Information and Analytical System of the City of Moscow (UMIAS).

Material and methods. To study public opinion, the practice of population survey was used, which was conducted through direct interviewing with filling out questionnaires of visitors to Moscow polyclinics and the method of questioning doctors based on a questionnaire developed by researchers. To analyze the data, the authors used general scientific methods of cognition, including the dialectical method, a systematic approach, logical correspondence and harmonization, detailing and generalization. As part of the study, the index value of the patient loyalty to the medical institution (MI) was calculated according to Net Promoter Score (NPS) method as the difference between the share of the “Promoters” group and the share of the “Critics” group in the total number of responses.

Results and discussion. The established correlations indicate the opinions of doctors and citizens to coincide and the UMIAS data on the issue of assessing the accessibility of admission of level 1 doctors for citizens. Based on the results of a sociological survey, the number of dissatisfied patients is mainly affected by managing medical care and its availability. The study confirmed that the higher the availability of an appointment with a level 1 doctor, the lower the number of visits the doctor on duty.

Conclusion. The conducted research has shown the practicality of an integrated approach to evaluating 
the activities of medical organizations based on the results of public opinion research and UMIAS data.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):411-417
pages 411-417 views

Oncology calculator as a tool for optimizing drug provision for patients with malignant neoplasms in the subjects of the Russian Federation

Linnik S.A., Tumenko E.E.

Abstract

Introduction. The increase in financial resources on the part of the state for the procurement of medicines for treating patients with malignant neoplasms makes the issue of calculation the need in medicinal preparations (MP) actual.

The aim of the work is to develop a special tool (oncology calculator) that standardizes the method for determining the need for drugs and can calculate the need for medications for the treatment of malignant neoplasms in a particular constituent entity of the Russian Federation.

Material and methods. To develop an oncology calculator, we analyzed the need for the drugs for the treatment of patients with the most common malignant neoplasms was analyzed based on current clinical guidelines approved and published on the Ministry of the Russian Federation website. The number of patients at each stage of a specific cancer was calculated. The frequency of application of a particular treatment regimen was calculated based on the approved standards of medical care for patients with cancer or from a project. The number of patients was calculated on the official statistics presented in the P.A. Hertsen Moscow Oncological Research Institute — branch of the Federal State Budgetary Institution “National Medical Research Center of Radiology” by the Ministry of Health of Russia. 

Results. We have developed a tool called the “Oncology calculator” that standardizes the methodology for determining the need of a constituent entity of the Russian Federation or a medical institution for drugs based on clinical guidelines, as well as facilitating the planning of the volume of medical care in the conditions of round-the-clock and day hospitals, and in the provision of medical care to patients with malignant neoplasms in outpatient settings.

Conclusion. The existing approaches to calculating the need for drugs for the treatment of patients with cancer in the constituent entities of the Russian Federation are scattered, which leads to the ineffective use of funds from the federal budget, compulsory medical insurance funds, budgets of the constituent entities of the Russian Federation. A uniform approach to calculating the need for drugs to treat malignant neoplasms should be based on clinical guidelines containing drug regimens for treating patients.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):418-424
pages 418-424 views

PROBLEMS OF SOCIALLY SIGNIFICANT DISEASES

Population awareness of depression and treatment methods

Golenkov A.V., Bonkalo T.I., Kamynina N.N., Shmeleva S.V.

Abstract

Aim. To study the population of the Chuvash Republic awareness of depression and methods of its treatment. 

Material and methods. Seven hundred sixty-four residents of the Chuvash Republic (472 women, 292 men) aged 18 to 83 years old (average age — 35.5 ± 14,3 years old) were interviewed anonymously. Urban residents were 75.5%, rural — 24.5%, with medical education — 5.9%. Two K. Griffiths et al. vignettes described patients with normal depressive state and depression accompanied by suicidal thoughts. After reading the picture, the respondents had to answer seven short questions. Mathematical and statistical processing included the calculation of the mean, standard deviation and χ2 distribution. 

Results. 39.0% of the respondents correctly identified the state of depression in the vignettes. This mental disorder was reliably better recognized by the respondents with a medical or higher education, urban residents and those who met such patients in life. The respondents most often (44,5%) recommended receiving psychological assistance, consultations and medical treatment (33,5%). They often suggested various “popular interventions”, did not know which specialists to contact and how to treat such a pathology, or suggested doing nothing at all, even if there were suicidal thoughts. More than 75% of the respondents expressed an improvement in patients’ condition in the case of their referring to specialists, the best results were given by the respondents who correctly recognized depression. 

Conclusion. The study showed a low level of depression awareness of the population of Chuvashia. This circumstance is reflected in the appeal of the people for medical (psychiatric, psychotherapeutic) help and expectations regarding the treatment of this mental disorder. A high proportion of incorrect answers about depression require educational work with the population, better psychiatric preparedness of specialists in the psychological profile and doctors of the general somatic network.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):425-431
pages 425-431 views

The specifics of the physiological stress of the population in self-isolation due to the COVID-19 pandemic

Polyakova O.B., Bonkalo T.I.

Abstract

Introduction. The COVID-19 pandemic has forced national governments to take measures to prevent the spread of coronavirus. Self-isolation as one of the forms of protection against infection with viral diseases has led to an increase in physiological stress.

The purpose of the study is to identify the specifics of the physiological stress of the population in self-isolation due to the COVID-19 pandemic.

Material and methods. The study involved 638 students (average age — 23.38 years) undergraduate, specialist and graduate programs of full-time and part-time forms of analysis who went online during the period of self-isolation via Skype to participate in training sessions. Questionnaires were used: “What stress are you experiencing?” (P. Legeron), “Inventory of stress symptoms” (T. Ivanchenko), neuropsychic stress questionnaire (T.A. Nemchin), Toronto alexithymia scale (G.J. Taylor, D. Ryan, R.M. Bagby). Mathematical and statistical data processing — K. Pearson’s correlation criterion and Chaddock’s table.

Results. Both the average level of physiological stress (6.74) and its components with a high connection were revealed: severity, increase, duration and frequency of neuropsychic stress (0.84, 0.86, 0.76, 0.86); disturbed sleep and wakefulness (0.82); negative sensations of the activity of the cardiovascular system (0.79), respiratory organs (0.80); pain and temperature sensations (0.73 and 0.75); drop in muscle tone (0.81); physical discomfort (0.84); increased susceptibility to external stimuli (0.87); decreased physical activity (0.79).

Discussion. The results of studies by domestic and foreign doctors and psychologists confirm the need for diagnostics, prevention and correction of all types of stress conditions and levelling of physiological stress.

Conclusion. The revealed specificity of physiological stress (pain in different parts of the body, dizziness and headaches, poor sleep, stiffness of movements, difficulty in breathing, an increase in the amount of food, coffee, cigarettes, fatigue, heart palpitations and physical stress) provides a basis for the management of primary and secondary prevention of general, physiological and emotional stress with the involvement of doctors, physiologists and psychologists.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):432-439
pages 432-439 views

PREVENTION OF NONINFECTIOUS DISEASES

Prevention of noncommunicable diseases: from risk factors to the national programs

Potemkina R.A., Mylnikova L.A., Kamynina N.N., Pivovarova O.A.

Abstract

Introduction. High mortality from noncommunicable diseases (NCDs) leads to significant economic losses, both direct associated with increasing costs for the health system and indirect associated with a decrease in labour potential due to disability and premature mortality of the population. It is known that the same risk factors (RF) determine the occurrence of major chronic diseases. To reduce mortality rates, it is necessary to change the population’s risk profile to reduce the prevalence of RF.

Goal. To identify the health effects of major non-communicable diseases in Russia by monitoring risk factors.

Оbjectives:
1. Determine the structure and weight of risk factors for noncommunicable diseases.
2. Study systems for monitoring the risk factors of non-communicable diseases.
3. Analyse international and domestic experiences in the prevention of major non-communicable diseases. 

Material and methods. Statistical compilations by Rosstat, Ministry of Health of Russia. Medline database was used to find some sources.

Results. The creation of an evidence-based health policy and strategy is based on a well-organized, reliable information system. Monitoring the NCD RF by regularly examining representative samples using standard methods is critical for such a system. Regular assessment of the population’s risk profile allows tracking the dynamics of health indicators and predicting mortality rates. Monitoring RF can assess the effectiveness of health care and population-based prevention programs in the regions and the country as a whole.

Conclusions. In addition to the influence of lifestyle and the physical and social environment, the health of the population depends on many components: the principles of the organization of the health system, it’s financing, and, to a large extent, on the standard of living of the population, income and their distribution in society. On this basis, health problems associated with various socio-economic, environmental and other living conditions of the population should be addressed jointly by many sectors and departments by creating a supportive physical and social environment for a healthy lifestyle of the population.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):440-446
pages 440-446 views

Correction of Selenium status as a tool for preventive medicine

Mazilina A.N., Skalny A.V., Rakitskii V.N., Rusanov A.S., Chernova L.N., Tinkov A.A.

Abstract

Introduction. Due to the many physiological functions of Selenium (Se), its deficiency is associated with a broad spectrum of adverse health effects. 

This review aims to analyze epidemiological data on the relation of selenium status to public health and the possibility of selenium-containing drugs usage. 

Material and methods. Based on the literature search in Pubmed, The Cochrane Library, and Google Scholar, epidemiological data on the association between Se status and population health and effects of Se supplementation were analyzed. 

Results. Meta-analyses indexed in the Cochrane Library demonstrated a significant association between Se status and many pathologies. Specifically, it has been shown that subjects with physiologically high Se body burden are characterized by a 24–31% lower risk of cancer and 36% lower risk of cancer-related mortality. It is also notable that Se supplementation in human immunodeficiency virus-infected women reduced the risk of maternal diarrhoea and low birth mass in offspring. Moreover, Se supplementation in premature newborns and critically low mass newborns significantly decreased the risk of sepsis. Many extensive epidemiological studies also demonstrated the efficiency of improvement in the Se status concerning coronary heart disease and sepsis mortality risk. At the same time, constant monitoring of Se body burden is essential for assessing Se supplementation efficiency and prevention of adverse health effects of Se overload. It is also noted that Se status is considered as the determinant of the efficiency of prevention of cardiovascular diseases and cancer under Se supplementation. 

Conclusion. Given the high incidence of Se deficiency in Russia (24–45% depending on the region), assessment and improvement of Se status may be considered a valuable tool for population health management.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):447-453
pages 447-453 views

OCCUPATIONAL MEDICINE

Professional models behavior of employees in the medical institutions

Alikperova N.V., Yarasheva A.V., Klyueva S.F., Vinogradova K.V.

Abstract

Introduction. The choice by medical personnel of a particular trend in their professional behaviour has a direct and significant impact on the functioning of health care institutions in general. The labour behaviour of doctors and nurses is determined by many different external factors and the formed personal characteristics of the health workers themselves.

The aim of the study. Identification of current models of professional behaviour of employees of the capital’s medical organizations.

Material and methods. Sociological research in the form of a mass survey of doctors and nurses; multivariate data analysis using structural and logical typology (factor and cluster analysis).

Results. The selection of four models of professional behaviour of employees of the capital’s medical organizations based on factor analysis (matrix of factor loadings) has been substantiated. The four models shown reflect the relationship between the personal characteristics of the personnel of healthcare institutions and working conditions (the ability to qualitatively fulfil the responsibilities for the provision of medical services and build a professional career).

Discussion. The differences in the preference for behavioural trends of doctors and nurses in the workplace revealed in the study showed an uneven distribution by behavioural models: the greater importance of professional (qualification) qualities for some and personal characteristics for others.

Conclusion. The systematization of behavioural models of medical personnel is in demand from the standpoint of the need to make effective management decisions in healthcare institutions in situations where it is necessary to identify and remove obstacles to achieving specific goals: increasing job satisfaction and providing quality medical care.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):454-460
pages 454-460 views

PROBLEMS OF MEDICAL EDUCATION

Problems of formalization of the mentoring institute in healthcare and ways of solving them

Burdastova Y.V.

Abstract

Introduction. This study focuses on the formalization of the institution of mentoring in health care. The mentoring system in Russia has existed for a long time. Still, there is a particular interest in this topic since the requirements for the quality of medical care are changing, new challenges arise in the healthcare sector, and reducing staff turnover and retaining highly qualified specialists in the workplace arises.

Targets and goals. The aim of the study is to clarify the need for institutional consolidation of the institution of mentoring. The tasks of the work included identifying factors motivating or demotivating medical workers to participate in the mentoring system, as well as the search for problems of formalizing the institution of mentoring.

Material and methods. The author conducted a sociological study in Moscow: a mass questionnaire survey among doctors and nurses in 6 medical institutions subordinated to the Department of Health of the city of Moscow and a series of in-depth structured interviews with representatives of medical organizations in charge of mentoring in their organizations (17). Analysis of quantitative data was carried out using the construction of classification trees using the CHAID method.

Results. The main issue that experts propose to spell out when formalizing mentoring is the skills and abilities. Employee willingness to become mentors varies. The study found that physicians over the age of 27 are most likely to become mentors convinced of the need to introduce and expand mentoring in the workplace. Young doctors under the age of 27 are less likely to take on the mentoring function due to a lack of confidence in their qualifications, as well as older colleagues who are dissatisfied with the working conditions in the workplace and do not consider it necessary to introduce or expand a mentoring system in their organization.

Conclusion. The study showed that experts have a positive attitude to ​​formalizing the institute of mentoring, noting that there should be a single document of a recommendatory nature.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):461-466
pages 461-466 views

Factors of dysfunction of institutes for assessing the qualifications of medical specialists

Kolennikova O.A., Toksanbaeva M.S.

Abstract

Introduction. The ongoing transformations of institutes for assessing the qualifications of medical specialists lead to ambiguous consequences, including the phenomena of their dysfunction. 

The aim of the study is to systematize the factors influencing the formation of the dysfunctions on the examples of the institute for accreditation of medical specialists and their certification for a qualification category.

Material and methods. The concepts of continuing education and continuing professional development, formulated under the auspices of the United Nations, served as the theoretical basis of the study. They were the basis for the analysis of the factors causing deviations from these processes, that is, the dysfunction of the institutes for assessing the qualifications of medical professionals. The information of two sociological surveys of medical specialists employed in the system of the Moscow Healthcare Department was used, namely, a sample questionnaire survey and a survey by the method of expert interviews.

Results. The factors of dysfunction of the institute of accreditation of medical specialists were identified on the basis of an analysis of the practice of continuing medical education (CME), introduced as an integral element of the transition from the institute of certification to the institute of accreditation. The main attention is paid to the shortcomings of the CME, which cause the dysfunctions of this institute. It is revealed that they are caused by an insufficiently debugged organization of the CME. The study of the work of the institute of certification for a qualification category showed that its main function, namely, ensuring permanent professional development above the accreditation level, has significantly weakened. This is confirmed by the statistics of a decrease in specialists undergoing both primary and secondary certification. One of the main factors is a violation of the incentives for professional growth.

Discussion. The problems of dysfunction of qualification assessment institutes are mainly because the coordination of their elements is not sufficiently observed in the work of these institutes. Within the framework of the accreditation institute, this is reflected in the fact that the distribution of responsibilities between all the subjects of the CME is poorly coordinated. And in the work of the institute of certification for a qualification category, its fundamental differences from the institute of accreditation are erased, mainly due to symbolic surcharges for the type and attempts to replace them with incentive payments common to both institutes.

Conclusion. The factors of dysfunction of the institutes for assessing the qualifications of medical specialists are systematized into main and concretized (as forms of manifestation of the main factors). The necessity of joint responsibility of the subjects of the CME for its quality, adequate to ensure the basic level of qualification, and strengthening the financial and career incentives for professional growth above the basic level, is substantiated.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):467-476
pages 467-476 views

LITERATURE REVIEW

Assessment of global research directions in medicine (literature review)

Pivovarova O.A., Aksenova E.I., Kamynina N.N.

Abstract

The identification of research fronts and the setting of priorities is a significant challenge in science and policy. 

The Global Research Front cluster of scientific articles is united by co-citing in other papers at a particular time. SciVal (online platform for monitoring and analyzing international research using visualization tools and modern citation metrics, economic and social efficiency) has three subject areas: Clinical Medicine, health management, and public health. 

By the total number of articles and the share of the direction in the research area of InCites Citation Topics, determine the global research fronts: neuroscanning, immunology, diet, orthopaedics and psychiatry. Today, the world is witnessing large-scale scientific programmes aimed at understanding human beings and their health. Because of the growing burden of significant brain diseases worldwide, scientists need to find effective means to apply modern biotechnology fully and address current clinical medicine issues. 

The threats of infectious diseases and the development of new vaccines have reinforced the pronounced response of the Global Immunology Observatory and related products in the field of system immunology. 

The scientific communities have embarked on a comprehensive consultation that should lead to a global strategy on diet and diet, physical activity, and reducing musculoskeletal and musculoskeletal diseases. 

Orthopaedic surgeons are developing new procedures and technologies to optimize patient care based on a science-based approach. 

The scale of mental health problems is at the heart of the global health and development plan of the World Bank, WHO and other national and international organizations, highlighting the scale of these challenges and successes that can be achieved if we work together to solve them.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):477-484
pages 477-484 views

Urodynamic studies and features of anaesthesia during intradetrusor botulinum therapy in the context of the COVID-19 pandemic (literature review)

Lysachev D.A., Khodyreva L.A., Stroganov R.V., Kupriyanov Y.A.

Abstract

The coronavirus pandemic has had a severe impact on the health care system. It is also changing the appointment and conduct of diagnostic procedures, emergency and routine medical care. 

According to the medical guidelines of the European Society of Urology (EAU) for the provision of urological care during the current epidemic situation, various levels of urgency have been proposed for diagnostic and therapeutic measures depending on the type of disease. Urodynamic studies refer to studies with a priority level from P2 (for neurogenic dysfunction of the urinary tract) to P4 (for lower urinary tract dysfunction without the risk of damage to the upper urinary tract). The question arises regarding the safety of these studies, both for patients and medical staff, and possible measures to reduce the risk of infection in a viral pandemic. 

Because of the increased workload of hospitals that have not been redesigned for the fight against coronavirus infection and provide routine and emergency urological care, an even greater need has arisen to find effective and safe methods of local anaesthesia for performing urodynamic studies and intradetrusive injections of botulinum toxin type A under local anesthesia in outpatient and outpatient settings (for example, in a short-term hospital). 

This article presents a literature review on the principles and features of performing urodynamic studies in the context of the Covid-19 pandemic and the effectiveness and safety of using various methods of local anaesthesia when performing intradetrusor injections of botulinum toxin with detrusor hyperactivity of a neurogenic and non-neurogenic nature. There were evaluated forms of local anaesthesia such as intradetrusor instillation of lidocaine, electrophoresis, and the use of alternative solutions for urinary bladder irrigation (for example, Ringer’s solution).

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):485-491
pages 485-491 views

Particularities of quality and safety control in cancer care (literature review)

Andreev D.A., Zavyalov A.A.

Abstract

Introduction. Last decade significant progress was made in the development of cancer care algorithms. In this regard, new challenges are constantly being presented to the quality control of medical activities in actual practice.

Aims. To summarize the outlines regarding the most relevant criteria for assessing the quality in oncology.

Material and methods. The PubMed database (Medline) was used to identify the relevant and reliable sources of literature. The thematic methodology for obtaining information was used. 

Results. In total, over 80 most significant publications were identified, thoroughly studied and analyzed. International experience indicates the advantages for assessing the quality of cancer care by determining and measuring certain indicators. The model for quality assessment proposed by Donabedian A. (1966) is broadly applied in current medical practice. This model distinguishes the following: 1) structural indicators, 2) process indicators, 3) outcome indicators. Feedback is critically important in the organization of the audit of medical activities. It allows one to adapt the assessment methods by focusing on the tasks immediately during the control process. Because of cancer heterogeneity, there are apart requirements for developing quality indicators for each specific type of cancer because of cancer heterogeneity. 

Conclusions. Monitoring of medical activities is a crucial pillar for a robust healthcare system. The introduction of essential, practical and specialized audit techniques helps to improve the quality and safety of medical technologies used in cancer care. There is an increasing need to develop optimal indicators and standard operating procedures for the control of cancer care.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):492-497
pages 492-497 views

Health information — relevance and accessibility (literature review)

Pivovarova O.A., Kamynina N.N., Skulkina Y.N., Korotkova E.O.

Abstract

Introduction. Health literacy directly impacts global health, social indicators, family relationships, and individual health behaviour. A fundamental element of an effective health system is information for the population on the protection and management of their health and those for whom they are responsible. As an essential skill, medical literacy is necessary for searching, understanding, and analyzing medical data from various sources. Improving people’s health literacy is critical to achieving responsibility for health.

Aim. Analysis of the formation and impact of health literacy on the achievement of sustainable development and other health objectives.

Material and methods. Literature search methods included search queries on Web of Science, Scopus, MedLine, The Cochrane Library databases.

Results. Global access to essential health information is not reflected in official monitoring, indicating the need to improve access to health information to provide more effective care.

The availability and use of reliable health information depend on the integrity of the global health information system. A systemic approach to the problem demonstrates the vital contribution of a vast number and variety of «components”, including health research, publication and dissemination of such research, systematic reviews, Development of guidelines and many different secondary outputs for users.

Conclusion. Lack of access to health information is a social injustice that the world health community cannot afford to ignore. Access to essential health information is a prerequisite and a component of achieving universal health coverage.

Health Сare of the Russian Federation. 2021;65(5):498-502
pages 498-502 views